5 Reasons We Ripped Out Our Wood-burning & Converted to a Gas Fireplace!

The other (and even better) half of our gas fireplace design makeover was converting the interior to gas. Ours was a wood-burning fireplace, and we used it as such for several years before we both woke up and decided life would be so much easier if we converted it into a gas fireplace!

(And trust us, we LOVE a real wood-burning fireplace. So why make the change?)

Why We Converted to a Gas Fireplace:

The 5 Pros of (the Right) Gas Fireplace!

Pro #5: Speed:

We could have a roaring fire immediately. Whenever we wanted.

Click to read our new plaster fireplace post!

#4: Timing:

We could turn off said roaring fire immediately whenever we wanted (and not have to worry about the timing of our fire, such as “Oh, let’s cozy up with a fire…wait, we got the kids to bed so late tonight that now it’s so late it’s not worth all the hassle…”).

#3: Flexibility:

We could have a fire going for 10 hours; we could have a fire going for 10 minutes. Whatever worked for our schedule that night or day.

#2: Low maintenance:

Less hassle with the following: Wood inside. Wood outside. Wood too wet. Spiders in wood. Did we kill all the spiders. Will this wood burn well. Kids playing in wood. Storage. Splinters. Etc.

#1: Cleanliness:

Again, wood. Wood chips. Spiders in wood. Ashes. Smoke. Etc.


The Cons

The major drawback? Let’s call it “Faux Alert!” I pretty much think ALL fake wood fireplaces look…well, fake. I can get reeeeeeally picky about things being natural and looking real.

But the practicality and function of this gas-burning fireplace idea was so tempting that you know I had to begin the hunt to find the most realistic log set possible for our two fireplaces (one in our living room and one in our master bedroom). I was convinced it had to be out there…somewhere…


Finding the Best, Most Realistic Gas Fire Logs!

If you’ve been thinking about converting your fireplace and have no idea where to start, Matt has written a post on exactly how to do that, step-by-step. And if you (like me) love REAL wood-burning fireplaces and are nervous about the log set looking fake, let me save you some time.

Because, my friend, I vetted SO many log sets. I went to showrooms. I ordered (and returned) online sets. I set up testers in my house, in real light, with no internet-fancy-photography-lighting, and saw which ones worked and which ones didn’t. Call me a Crazy Person, or call me a Brilliant Determined-to-Have-the-Real-Wood-Look-Without-Wood Woman…but the great news is that I did all the leg work for you and found one that passed The Jess Test!

No one has paid me for this; I’ve never even communicated with anyone at this company. I just really and truly found the best looking gas fireplace logs (and at a totally reasonable price, because you know we like that).


Bonus Gas Fireplace Design Notes!

I’ll just mention two more things before passing you on to Matt’s post about how to do it easily yourself. (Really, he makes things so easy! Whereas his wife—ahem—has been occasionally known to complicate them…)

DESIGN TIP #1: Don’t paint the fire box!

We purposefully left our fireplace interior (the firebox) unpainted before putting in the gas log set. I liked the look that all the real wood fires over the years had created inside the firebox. Now THAT was natural! While some people like the look of a perfectly clean, painted firebox in the background, I liked the real fire look our firebox had acquired. Thus we left them the way you see here.

DESIGN TIP #2: Create your own log layout!

As per usual, I wasn’t satisfied with the configurations the manufacturer instructed us to use for arrangements. (Theirs looked too fakey to me when I did my test arrangements.) So, again as usual, I made up my own layout. I also arranged them so that the fire would come up through the logs in a much more realistic way. This does leave some dark marks on the logs but again, I like that because real wood gets char marks too.

And I was allllllll about finding every way possible to make this look like a real wood fireplace. Doesn’t this look like a fire just waiting to be lit? I think so! My Faux-o-Meter does not go off!

gas fireplace with white painted stone facade and split oak logs in fireplace
We go over the 3 crazy easy steps we did to paint our stone fireplace. I just love it!

And here it is lit. (In an instant. It’s SO much better. It kills me that it took us so long to convert our fireplaces, we’re enjoying them so much!)

gas fireplace with white painted stone facade and split oak logs in fireplace lit
Join our Insider’s List and get our FREE Design Guide!

Even when it’s unlit, I am SOOOOOOOOOOOO happy with how real it looks. I can’t put enough O’s in that. I see it all the livelong day out of the corner of my eye (our kitchen looks right into this room).

white stone fireplace with gas fireplace logs in living room with neutral decor

mirror | plates | vase | basket | Expert Room Design & Layout Guide

Zero mess. Instant fires on and off. No hassle. There are lovely-looking logs always in my fireplace, inviting us to come cozy up and enjoy a slower pace.

No exaggerations here: it’s been lifestyle-changing for us.

stone fireplace painted white with white mantel and neutral decor

mirror | vase | basket | We discovered the simplest way to convert our fireplace to gas!

DESIGN TIP #3: Should You Avoid a TV Over Your Fireplace?

living room with TV behind panel above gas fireplace

TV above fireplace: should you do it…or avoid it?

We’re sharing our insights in this post!


See the makeover of how we painted our stone fireplace white here, or read Matt’s clear step-by-step post showing you exactly how to convert your fireplace to a gas one. (It’s so doable that even his wife could do it!)

*This post contains affiliate links, which are no extra cost to you but help us keep this site alive!

living room with fireplace and mantel with stone or stucco surround
See all our home projects & designs HERE!

This Post Has 8 Comments

  1. Daisy James

    I loved how you said that you won’t have to worry about a lot of maintenance with gas fireplaces. My cousin was at my house yesterday afternoon for lunch, and she talked about how she and her fiance want to get a fireplace installed in their home within the next couple of weeks. I’ll pass this information along to her so she can know the advantages of having a gas fireplace.

    1. Jess

      Nice! Glad it helped!

  2. Brenda Cano

    I loved your piece and am looking to do the same with our fireplace but like you hate the fake look. When I hit the place where you posted which one you chose it took me to Walmart site and said this page was unavailable. Please help a girl out. Thank you so much.

    1. Matt

      Hi Brenda, so glad you found us! Here is the link to the fire logs with burner set.


    2. Jess

      Hi Brenda, the link is working for us. You might try on a different computer or device! 🙂

      – Jess

  3. Kaley

    Hi! Thank you for the helpful info! I see the link to the log set no longer works. Any chance you have the details of the company or anything? Thank you!

Leave a Reply